Nick Robson
ANAESTHESIA BREATHING SYSTEMS
References:
- Russell;
- Dorsch and Dorsch;
- Scurr and Feldman;
- Conway - BJA (1985), 57, 649-657 - Symposium edition;
- McIntyre - Can. Anaesth. Soc J (1986), 33:1; 98-105
- Brown and Fisk - Anaesthesia for Children.
CLASSIFICATION
Several different nomenclatures in existence, eg
- Open system - FGF derived from atmosphere, and extraneous dead
space does not exist, eg early phase of inhalational induction in
children.
- Semi-open system - Fresh gas is atmospheric, partly delivered
by apparatus and therefore added VD exists, eg Schimmelbusch mask.
(needed added O2 in open ether anaesthesia to prevent hypoxaemia).
- Closed system - Totally closed to atmosphere, FG added as
utilisation occurs and CO2 efficiently "scrubbed" eg WW II
commando underwater breathing apparatus.
- Semi-Closed systems - Closed to atmosphere with FG provided at
rates > utilisation with venting of XS gas.
Further subdivided:
- semi-closed absorption systems;
- semi-closed rebreathing systems;
- non-rebreathing systems.
Confusing and cumbersome, because the same systems are frequently
referred to by different people using a variety of names.
Makes sense to classify in terms of their geometry (Conway - 1985)
into 2 broad classes , ie, systems:
- WITHOUT or,
- WITH the means for CO2 absorption.
The majority of systems allocated to the first group are the
"Mapleson" systems. These are rebreathing systems, since the
potential exists for expired CO2 rebreathing.
The second group contains CO2 absorption circuits, of which the
CIRCLE is most commonly in use. (Watters "to-and-fro" circuit is the
other configuration). These have a means of CO2 absorption and
utilising one-way valves mechanically separating inspired and expired
gases, can virtually eliminate expired CO2 rebreathing.
Non-rebreathing circuits exist also with a NRB valve close to the
patient's airway to vent expired gases eg Laerdal resuscitation
bags.
McIntyre (1986) classifies into 2 groups also:
- CO2 washout circuits -
- Open - (no reservoir bag)
- open mask, drop anaesthesia, eg open ether
- Insufflation
- T-piece.
- Semi-open - (reservoir bag) - Mapleson's.
- CO2 absorption circuits -
- Closed - (FGF = patient uptake)
- Semi-closed - (FGF > uptake)
Three main functions of anaesthesia circuits are:
- delivery of anaesthetic gases and vapours;
- oxygenation of the patient; and
- CO2 elimination.
Open circuits are of historic interest only apart from paediatric
induction supplementing ambient air with high flow O2/N2O delivered
by a hose into the anaesthetist's cupped hands.
A. CARBON DIOXIDE WASHOUT CIRCUITS
1. MAPLESON A - (Magill) CIRCUIT
FGF enters at the end remote from the patient. Behaviour varies
markedly between spontaneous and controlled ventilation:
(a) Spontaneous ventilation
- Expiratory valve close to the patient therefore alveolar gas
tends to be selectively vented during spontaneous ventilation.
- Early in expiration, exp. gas enters the corrugated tube at
the same time as FG enters the reservoir bag, pressure increases
and late in exp. gas (alveolar) is vented from the ex. valve.
- A "front" of FG enters along the corrugated tube, and exp. gas
from early expiration is then vented. Theoretically FGF = 0.7 x
Valv should prevent significant rebreathing. Said to be an
efficient system because end-inspiratory VD gas (no CO2) is
available for rebreathing.
- Difficult to predict exact composition of inspired gas
reaching patient.
- FGF sl. > Valv (6-8 l.min-1) recommended in adults to
reliably eliminate rebreathing in spontaneous breathing.
(b) Controlled ventilation
- Exp. valve opens during inspiration, therefore alveolar gas is
retained within the system, because low pressures within the
circuit do not open the relief valve, and expired gas remains
within the circuit.
- Increasing FGF will decrease magnitude of RB, but not
recommended for CV modes unless ETCO2 measurement available.
2. MAPLESON B & C SYSTEMS
- Least commonly used.
- FGF near patient relief valve also near patient, corrugated
tubing (B only) and reservoir bag.
- Have a "blind limb" requiring FGF > 2.5x Vmin to avoid CO2
rebreathing.
- Because of the proximity of the FGF and relief valve, during
end expiratory pause, fresh gas is preferentially vented. High FGF
will reduce rebreathing, but "blind end " constitutes large VD
volume.
- Only contemporary use is as resuscitation bag and mask set
ups. Mapleson C same without corrugated tubing.
3. MAPLESON D, E and F SYSTEMS
- Identical geometry at the patient end - gas disposition at
their T end determines their function.
- FGF at patient end, relief valve between the corrugated tubing
and the reservoir bag, (D system). Length of tubing of no
importance provided reservoir volume > VT.
- In all, FG exclusively constitutes the inspired gas provided
FGF is > PIFR - ie > 3x Vmin.
- Suitable for use with both IPPV and spont. ventilation.
- FGF in XS of patients needs enters reservoir tubing/bag at end
exp'n, (particularly if a pause is present), and early
inspiration, flushing out expired gas. If this volume = VT the
entire insp. volume is fresh gas. (FGF = Vmin x2 required for this
to pertain).
4. BAIN MODIFICATION OF THE MAPLESON D SYSTEM
- Bain and Spoerel 1972 for use in head and neck cases.
- Coaxial T piece system.
- Outer tubing 22 mm diameter and 1.8m long. FG tubing inside
the expiratory tube - decreases bulk.
- Functionally same as Mapleson D.
- Can safely be used during spontaneous respiration with a FGF =
100 ml.kg.min-1, but instability introduced because of variation
in VT/VD ratio, resp. wave form, VCO2 and Vmin during anaesthesia.
All will influence the fresh gas requirements.
Numerous formulae exist to predict FG requirements in spont.
breathing:
- F.G.F.= 2-3x VE
- F.G.F.= 100 ml.kg.min-1
- F.G.F.= 3x VE
- F.G.F.= 2x VE
- F.G.F.= 8 l.min-1 unless VCO2 > 250 ml.min-1
- F.G.F.= 2.5 x 6 x body wt (kg) x f(15 x kg x f)
- F.G.F.= 4,000 ml.min.m-2 BSA.
Capnography has removed the "hit and miss" nature of these
calculations. FGF > 6-8 l.min-1 in an adult should be adequate, ie
> 70-100 ml.kg.min-1.
Rebreathing does occur but increased Vmin in spontaneous respiration
will prevent CO2 retention, (unless respiratory depressants used in
large doses).
During controlled ventilation, FGF of 70 ml.kg.min-1 and Vmin
=120-150ml.kg.min-1 adequate to prevent significant rebreathing,
although this nearly always occurs to a degree (unless FGF > 3x
minute ventilation ie ~ 200-250 ml.kg.min-1).
Advantages of Bain circuit:
- (a) For the patient:
- Low resistance,
- Easy to sterilise,
- (b) For the anaesthetist:
- Light weight, minimal apparatus at ETT,
- Easy to scavenge,
- Easy to connect to ventilator for IPPV,
- No Valves,
- SV or PPV equally simple,
- Inexpensive materials,
- Useful for all ages.
Problems with Bain circuits:
- many connections therefore disconnection risk increased;
- detachment of inner tube from machine end, or FG tube
kinks/blocks Æ entire exp. (outer) tube becomes VD,
- integrity of inner tube can be a problem - can overlook small
holes = leaks. Checked by occluding with flow-meter running and
should observe a fall in rotameter bobbin.
- uneconomical on fresh gas utilisation.
- Checking integrity of both inner and outer tubes:
- Venturi effect emptying reservoir bag using O2 flush,
- pressure test in standard fashion.
5. LACK COAXIAL SYSTEM - (Modification of Magill)
Coaxial with FGF down large diameter outer corrugated tube,
functionally resembling the Magill. Inner narrow tube is connected to
the expiratory valve.
FGF = VE avoids significant rebreathing in spont. ventilation (ie FGF
> 70 ml.kg-1).
During spontaneous ventilation gas taken from the outer tube and the
reservoir bag, which have been filled (depending upon FGF rate)
during the inspiratory pause.
In CV same flow considerations apply as with the Magill.
During expiration, the bag fills and XS gas is vented along the inner
tube to the relief valve. At end insp'n the inner tube contains only
exp. gas, and the outer tube contains exp. gas near the patient, and
some FG near the machine and within the reservoir bag. During the
exp. pause, the FG drives the exp. gas out of the inner tube to the
vent valve. In CV FGF > 150 ml.kg.min-1prevents significant
rebreathing, unless Vmin 200ml.kg.min-1, when FGF becomes the CO2
controller and may be reduced to 100 ml.kg.min-1.
6. AYRE'S T-PIECE
Most important design features for paediatric anaesthetic use
include:
- light weight;
- low resistance - ID > 1 cm suitable for children of 20-25
kg (valves add resistance, and may stick when moist, further
increasing R).
- low VD; and
- ease of use.
(Additionally desirable to conserve heat and moisture).
Original T-piece (Phillip Ayre 1937 - paediatric
neurosurgical/cleft-lip and palate repair) was modified by Jackson
Rees in 1950 & 1960, adding exp. limb to prevent air dilution and
an open-ended 500 ml bag to allow respiratory monitoring and/or
assistance.
Deadspace
Specific VD/VT ratio in children similar to adults, ie ~ 0.3 -
therefore 3 kg infant with VT=21ml has a VD = 7ml.
VD/VT increases in deep anaesthesia with spontaneous ventilation, and
can increase further if XS apparatus dead space is not limited. In
ATP and Bain, dead space volume is determined by:
- FGF, and
- apparatus VD between FG outlet and patient.
In SV, PaCO2 increases unless FGF > 2.5-3x Vmin.
In CV (IPPV), ATP results in relatively more rebreathing 2° to
higher PIFR.
Provided the FGF > Vmin, efficiency of CO2 washout is entirely
dependant on FGF. Mean level of PaCO2 depends on VCO2 minus CO2
removal. (ie since CO2 removal is dependent in a non-absorbent system
on FGF, the ETCO2 and PaCO2 depend on VCO2 and FGF).
The leak around ETTs in children is of little importance, as is the
loss of dead space when cutting ETT length.
ADVANTAGES:
- Simple and lightweight;
- VD minimal;
- Resistance is low - a slight increases in exp. resistance may
act like a low level of PEEP and help to offset the loss of FRC in
general anaesthesia;
DISADVANTAGES:
- High FGF necessary;
- Dry gases inhaled unless humidified;
- Atmospheric pollution unless scavenging in place;
- Expense prohibitive if N2O not available - ie O2 plus volatile
at high flows
B. CO2 ABSORPTION CIRCUITS
Most common in use today is the circle system.
Components -
- absorber and absorbent;
- FG inlet;
- unidirectional valves;
- pressure gauge;
- breathing tubes;
- reservoir bag;
- "Y" piece; and
- O2 sensor.
Optional extras include - bacterial filters, VIC vaporisers,
humidifiers (HMEs) etc.
1. ABSORBER AND ABSORBENT
Canister containing CO2 absorbent - soda lime - may be single or
dual, of metal, glass or (typically) plastic construction.
Intergranular space > VT, volume of air in a filled canister is
approx. 50% of total. Larger cross-sectional diameter allow less
turbulence with reduced resistance and less dust.
Correctly packed canisters allow absorption throughout, rather than
in a columnar fashion. Baffles in canister reduces gas tracking down
the walls, where spaces relatively larger.
Bypass mechanism can isolate absorber from circuit and allow PaCO2 to
occur without decreased minute ventilation.
Advantages of CO2 absorption
- lower FGF, improved economy;
- less pollution;
- heat and moisture are conserved;
- flammable gases and vapours (historically) contained.
- inhaled mixture composition is more constant.
Soda lime
- 4% NaHCO3, 1% KOH, 14-19% H2O and Ca(OH)2 to 100%.
- Silicates prevent powdering, and indicators alert to
exhaustion (below).
- Granule size 4-8 mesh; irregular surface shape to enhance
absorptive SA.
- 450g load of soda lime absorbs 47 litres of CO2 minimum (ie ~
25 L CO2 per 100 G)- ~4.5 hrs absorption at VCO2 = 150 ml.min-1.
- FGF of 50% Vmin increases the duration to ~ 8 hours.
- Exhausted when ~ 0.5% of CO2 is leaking through with mixed
exp. CO2 = 4%.
- Indicators - fresh soda lime has pH = 12 which decreases as
CO2 s absorbed.
- - white S/L contains ethyl violet, critical pH = 10.3;
- - pink S/L contains phenolphthalein, pHcrit = 7 - becomes
colourless as the NaHCO3 is exhausted.
- Heat in the canister
- Heat of neutralisation. No correlation between heat production
and remaining absorptive capacity.
- Hot canister may indicate
- - efficient absorption;
- - residual heat in an exhausted canister;
- - high patient VCO2;
- Signs of exhaustion
- Increased ETCO2;
- decreasing warmth of canister;
- colour change in indicator;
- signs of hypercapnoea in the patient.
2. FRESH GAS INLET
Connection between CGO and (usually) the inspiratory side of the
absorber top mount.
3. UNIDIRECTIONAL VALVES
2 in each circle system - inspiratory, and expiratory limbs. Attached
to the absorber usually, but can be located at the "Y" piece. 2 main
designs:
- disc valve on annular metal or neoprene seat, anchored or
within a cage;
- "flap" valves.
Valve requirements - low resistance essential, therefore large SA,
- light weight,
- lift-clearance of ~ 1/2 valve seat diameter.
Problems:
- incompetence most common - discs adhere to dome unless guard
fitted;
- wetting and/or sticking;
- guide pin holds disc open;
- electrostatic charges holding disc in dome;
- foreign material obstructing - eg S/Lime;
4. EXHALE VALVES - (pop-off, or adjustable pressure limiting
valves)
Designed to vent or spill XS gas from the circle. Generally combined
with scavenging collection assembly. Necessary in all circuits where
gases are vented by pressure from the circuit - eg circle, Bain,
Magill.
Minimum spill pressure sl.> that required to fill the reservoir
bag (< 2.5 cmH2O usually).
- Spont. respiration - opens at the end of exp. pause, and
should be set to a low opening pressure.
- Manual/assisted ventilation - set to the max. desired
inspiratory pressure, gases vented in inspiration, when preset
pressure exceeded.
- Mechanical IPPV - close completely, (theoretically only if
safety pressure relief valve is fitted).
(i) Heidebrink type
Disc valve seated on annular knife edge. Light spring connected to a
screw cap allows the opening pressure to be adjusted from 1-40 cmH2O,
beyond which valve is totally closed. Creates very little outflow
resistance. Initially mica, changed to metal, now mica again.
(ii) CIG - Medishield exhale valve
Similar principle, but differs in that it has a safety relief
mechanism activated at pressures > 50 cmH2O, with manual override
by depressing the tightening screw. Relieves at 2-50 cmH2O in normal
flow range, but relief pressure increases to 50-100 cmH2O at flows
> 30 l.min-1.
(iii) Berner valve
Three-position valve - behaves like Heidebrink at normal pressures,
ie opening at various spill pressures, fully closed and thirdly,
closes completely on sharp rise in pressure. Useful during hand
ventilation of a patient. Gas spill still occurs in expiration.
Avoids the need for adjustment if FGF is altered.
5. PRESSURE GAUGE - manometer
Attached to absorber, calibrated in cmH2O and mmHg with positive and
negative scales.
Anaeroid type.
Reflects changing pressures within the circuit, DOES NOT accurately
display Paw, because of resistance and compliance characteristics of
the components of the circuit, proximal to patient airway.
6. BREATHING HOSES
Function - gas conduit to patient (reservoir in some circuits).
Length does not influence VD within the circuit.
Black antistatic:
- nominal 22 mm nearer to 20 mm when new to ensure a tight
elastomeric fit.
- 1 meter hose has internal volume = 450 ml, and compliance = 1
ml.cmH2O-1.
- Can "bulge" on expiration and cause a small degree of
rebreathing - "backlash".
- 1 meter length has ~ 90 corrugations enabling it to be wound
into a 50 cm spiral without kinking.
- Pressure drop along a 1 m length of hose at 30 l.min-1 <
0.5 cmH2O.
Disposable polypropylene hoses
- similar ID ~ 20 mm but a smaller volume ~ 400 ml.m-1.
- less kink-resistant, less compliant - 0.5-0.8 ml.cmH2O-1.
- form pin-holes and splits more readily.
7. RESERVOIR BAG
Stores gas between respiratory cycles. Provides information to
anaesthetist in manual ventilation regarding pulmonary compliance and
airway patency. Rubber or neoprene construction. Antistatic -
resistance not less than 106 ohms.
Sizes from 500 ml - 5 litres.
> 2 litre bags have standard 22 mm connections.
2 l bags have 15 mm connections.
Compliance tested - inflated to 2.5 cmH2O and then filling continued
to 4x nominal volume. After deflation to P = 2.5 cmH2O again, should
not have increased volume by more than 10% and inflation pressure
should have been 30-50 cmH2O.
Can usually hold 10x nominal volume before bursting. Offers no
protection against pressure extremes in IPPV - 2 l bag has peak
pressure of > 75 cmH2O at 4x nominal volume.
8. "Y" PIECE
Plastic or metal. May house non-return valves. All have two standard
22 mm male connections to fit the breathing hoses. Patient connection
port is a 15 mm female fitting, OR a 15 mm female port coaxial within
a 22 mm male fitting.
Metal "Y" pieces require care with positioning around the face - risk
of nerve damage.
9. SENSOR FROM O2 ANALYSER
Fitted to a right angled portion of a "T" fitting located at the
inspiratory limb of the circuit - polarographic analyser commonly.
10 FITTINGS
- CGO coaxial 15/22 mm
- I & E ports on circle absorber 22 mm male - can be coaxial
with 15 mm female
- Reservoir bag 22 mm male
- Patient connection port coaxial 15/22 mm
- ETT connector 15 mm male - can also be 22 mm female with ID of
11 mm
- Breathing hoses 22 mm female at machine end
- Scavenging system 19 mm conical male